Market Corrections. How Bad Can They Get?
Market “pullbacks”, “corrections” and “bear markets”
Sharemarket declines are often labelled differently depending on the degree of share price losses sustained. Let’s talk about the semantics first: Although opinions can vary, the worst – but best known – sharemarket downturn is called a “bear market” which tends to be defined as a peak-to-trough decline in prices of 20% or more. By contrast, sharemarket declines of more than 10% (but less than 20%) are typically called “corrections“. Smaller market declines (less than 10%) go by many names, but I like to call them “pullbacks“. At the time of writing, the S&P 500 has already experienced a maximum decline of 10.1% from its closing recent peak of 2,872.8 on January 26 – placing this decline in the “correction” territory so far.
What do typical market declines look like?
As seen in the table below, market pullbacks are the most common form of market decline – analysing the US S&P 500 Index, there have been 466 pullbacks since the market recovery from the Great Depression(1), with an average decline of 1.5% taking place on average over one and a half weeks. Recovery on average takes a further week. Note the vast bulk of these pull backs (93%) involve declines of less than 5%. In short, market declines of 5% or less are very common and hard to get too worried about.
By contrast, there have been nine bear markets, with an average market decline in these periods of 35.8%, over an average of 65 weeks(2). On average it takes almost twice as long – 116 weeks – for the market to recover its previous (price) peak. As the saying goes, the market goes down the elevator but up the stairs.
What about corrections? The table indicates there have been 11 “corrections” which, perhaps surprisingly, is only slightly more than actual bear markets. Even if we include 10 to 20% market declines during a market recovery (i.e. before prices have reached their previous peak) the number of corrections grows to 13 – which still implies an average of only 1.4 corrections for every bear market.
All up, this analysis suggests that if we are truly in only a market correction then chances are that we’ve almost reached bottom. That said, it could take a few more weeks (even months) before the actual bottom is in place.
Has market behaviour changed over time?
To gain an insight into long-run trends over time, the chart below details the peak-to-trough declines in closing daily prices of the US S&P 500 Index over this period.
Just eyeballing the chart, it’s evident that overall market volatility does not appear to have appreciably lessened. If anything, since the early 1990s there have been two relatively extended periods of low volatility but also two relatively deep and more extended bear market periods. This is consistent with the “Great Moderation” in macro-economic volatility in recent decades, but also the potentially greater threat now posed by financial market imbalances in creating bear markets.
Indeed, the two greatest bear markets since the Great Depression also happen to be the two most recent – the early 2000s dotcom crash and the 2007-09 financial crisis.
(1) The Great Depression period was excluded because it was such an outlier in terms of the depth and length of the market downturn. It was instead decided to focus on the more recent post-war period – which still covers more than 50 years!